Just over one year ago, Old Overholt announced that its 10-year-old cask-strength rye (reviewed here) was hitting the market. The rare special edition release signaled parent company James B. Beam Distilling’s reignited investment in rye whiskey. Next was the “A. Overholt” special release expression made using the brand’s original 1810 recipe. The Old Overholt 11-year Cask-Strength bottling is Beam’s newest addition to its growing market presence.
While the exact mash bill is undisclosed, Old Overholt is undeniably rye-forward, partly due to the brand’s old-school approach. Beam distilled and barreled this whiskey in 2012, aging it in four on-premise warehouses, each with a unique climate. It then bottled the unfiltered whiskey 11 years later. The main difference between this release and its 10-year-old predecessor is the bottling proof; the 10-year was bottled at a bold 121 proof, and this expression is bottled at 107.4 proof.
Tasting Notes
The 11-year-old’s appearance is noticeably lighter than the 10-year-old, possibly due to the considerably lower proof. The light, rusty-straw-colored whiskey has thin, straight legs that grip and cascade down the edge of the snifter, slowly dissipating toward the bottom.
The nose is also less pungent than I expected. Still, classic rye-spice aromas, sweet and inviting French vanilla, and charred oaky goodness spring forth. The palate has a soft mouthfeel and a medium body, with intense spice notes of cracked black pepper and allspice. Richer notes of cherries and licorice mellow the spice, though, leading to a wonderfully crisp finish warm enough to linger between sips.
Old Overholt is well known for its classic whiskeys without frills or gimmicks. This whiskey is another excellent example of the brand’s simplicity: a straightforward, well-aged rye with a moderately elevated classic taste that remains familiar and dependable.
Final Thoughts
Old Overholt 11 Rye may not be the most extraordinary or complex pour, but it’s an approachable, straightforward rye that checks every box and provides all the loveable, indulgent traits of extended aging. While I was expecting something a bit bolder, the elegance, albeit somewhat tame character of this 11-year release was refreshing. I enjoyed it as much, if not more, than some extra aged ryes that aim to pack a punch. For an 11-year-old bottling that is a sure winner for any rye fan, it’s also a bargain at $99.99 USD!



0 Comments